Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Hotel franchisees turn to state lawmakers

Newly formed Fair Franchising Initiative holds launch conference, focuses on New Jersey bill

MORE THAN 300 Asian American hotel owners attended the March 5 kickoff of a new business organization that will focus on franchising in the hospitality industry.

Fair Franchising Initiative has its roots in New Jersey with plans to expand nationwide as it gains momentum by crafting and promoting legislation the organization says will balance the playing field in the franchiser-franchisee relationship.


Fair Franchising Initiative held the conference in a ballroom at Royal Albert’s Palace in Edison, New Jersey. During the three-hour event leaders of the initiative, hotel owners, lawyers and consultants spoke about the impact current franchising practices are having on their businesses as well as the industry overall.

President of the organization is Prakash Shah, a hotelier and owner of First Group Mortgage and Realty Group, an investment bank in New Jersey that specializes in commercial loans.

Chairman is Anil Patel, owner of Northstar Hotels in New Jersey.

The first steps

Fair Franchising Initiative’s flagship effort is A-2682, a hospitality-focused fair franchising proposal introduced in February in the New Jersey General Assembly. The group’s hope is the measure becomes law and sets off a nationwide revolution in the hotel franchising industry.

The proposed New Jersey measure would prohibit franchisers from certain acts, including:

  • Forcing an owner to spend more than $25,000 more than once every five years on property improvements unless the franchiser can demonstrate the franchisee would recover the value of investment during the contract term.
  • Receiving rebates or bonuses from brand-certified vendors that sell goods or services to the franchisee unless the deal is transparent in the franchise agreement.
  • Requiring franchisees to buy from specific vendors or service providers.
  • Making any unilateral changes to the original franchise agreement during the term of the licensing contract.
  • Financially penalizing owners for negative guest reviews.
  • Charging franchisees to resolve guest complaints via calls or emails to the franchiser’s corporate office.
  • Requiring owners to pay a fee for failing to enroll a specified number of loyalty members.

“This is a problem for all hoteliers over the country,” Shah said. “It’s a problem that we need a solution [for]. People are hurting and it’s not an easy situation they are in. Franchisers are taking advantage of the situation.”

One of the major concerns, Shah said, is the rising cost of guest acquisitions coming from various channels but mostly third-party agents.

“Ten years ago, an average franchiser was charging 7 or 8 percent and they would give you a lot of business in return,” he said. “Today, the business they give you has dwindled because a lot of the business is coming from third-party booking engines like Expedia, and they charge separately for providing that business. So, we’re paying double now for the same business.”

Shah said franchisers have increased their fees to 15 to 17 percent.

Taking it local

The Federal Trade Commission regulates franchising, but many, such as members of Fair Franchising Initiative who say there’s an imbalance in the system, are turning to states to produce laws that create more fairness in the industry.

Shah said New Jersey’s A-2682 is an attempt to lighten the financial burden on hotel owners/operators piled on by franchisers through various fees and penalties.

Along with lobbying New Jersey lawmakers, Fair Franchising Initiative members and hoteliers have launched efforts in other states such as California, Vermont and New York. Shah said the New Jersey bill, if it passes, would have a nationwide impact.

“These things have a cumulative effect,” he said. “We want to take the momentum from this bill in New Jersey and carry it to other states.”

‘We are part of AAHOA’

Anil Patel said as the initiative was organizing charter members asked if he could recruit supporters from past chairmen of AAHOA. Currently, Fair Franchising Initiative board members include past chairmen Mike Patel (1998-99); CK Patel (2010-11); and Hemant Patel (2011-12).

“The issues are clear,” Anil said, noting the initiative wanted experienced leaders to guide the initiative on its quest.

“We are not anti-AAHOA; we are part of AAHOA,” he said, adding he joined the association in the early 1990s.

The topic of fair franchising “has been around as long as we’ve been going to AAHOA meetings.” He sees the current board of directors easing up on the 12 Points of Fair Franchising as the association shifts its efforts to government affairs. He also attributes the shift in focus to new and younger board members who do not relate to the “sweat and blood” shed by charter AAHOA members to build their family businesses.

“Today, franchising is really getting out of control,” Anil said. “It’s a network of who you know and franchise contracts are not equal for all.”

Hoteliers are cutting their own deals with franchisers resulting in licensing agreements that are not uniform with contracts that most other hoteliers sign. The various agreements make it difficult to make sure franchisers adhere to the principals of fair franchising.

“The focus has been a little bit derailed,” he said.

Though most of the Fair Franchising Initiative conference attendees do business in New Jersey, many others have hotels throughout New England, the Mid-Atlantic, Southwest and Southern regions of the U.S.

A few hoteliers at the conference have properties in California, where the state Legislature in 2016 passed amendments to its Franchise Relations Act that places restrictions on franchisers’ decisions to terminate or not renew licenses. It also gives franchisees more freedom to sell their franchised business assets or add investors.

A newer act, AB-5, paves the way for a franchisee to hold a franchiser financially responsible under the state’s wage and hour laws if the franchisee’s business fails and the franchisee loses income as a result.

The International Franchise Association opposed the law, which was passed and signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom in September.

New Jersey Sen. Joseph Cryan, Democrat, District 20, spoke at Fair Franchising Initiative’s conference and vowed to support A-2682.

The bill’s primary sponsor is Assemblyman Raj Mukherji, Democrat, District 33, who introduced it to New Jersey’s General Assembly on Feb. 13.

Mukerji also spoke at the event and promised to move the bill to the House’s Judiciary Committee, which he chairs. He talked about the “lopsided” relationship between hotel franchisers and franchisees.

He said while there are federal laws that address franchising, “there are no laws that protect franchisees.”

“As policy makers, we have a responsibility to level the playing field.”

In February, Red Lion Hotels Corp. launched its “back to basics” plan as part of the company’s efforts to address franchisee concerns and stop a rising number of exits.

More for you

Breaking Barriers: Women of Color Power List 2025 Revealed

Breaking Barriers: Women of Color Power List 2025 Revealed

Women of Color Power List 2025 Debuts at AAHOACON 2025

ASIAN MEDIA GROUP USA, publisher of Asian Hospitality magazine, launched the first-ever “Women of Color Power List 2025” at the 2025 AAHOA Convention & Trade Show in New Orleans, honoring 51 women reshaping the U.S. hospitality industry. The publication is the first to spotlight the achievements of women of color, recognizing their resilience, innovation, and leadership.

Asian Media Group Managing Editor Kalpesh Solanki, Executive Editor Shailesh Solanki, and Chief Operating Officer Aditya Solanki announced the list during the conference.

Keep ReadingShow less
AAHOALending.com લોન્ચ 2025

AAHOA, બ્રિજ AAHOALending.com લોન્ચ કરે છે

AAHOA અને બ્રિજે AAHOALending.com ને AAHOACON 2025 માં રજૂ કર્યું

AAHOA અને બ્રિજે AAHOALending.com લોન્ચ કર્યું, જે હોસ્પિટાલિટી પર કેન્દ્રિત ડિજિટલ ધિરાણ પ્લેટફોર્મ છે. તે AAHOA સભ્યોને 150 થી વધુ ધિરાણકર્તાઓની ઍક્સેસ પ્રદાન કરે છે, જેમાં વધુને વધુ લોકોને નિયમિતપણે ઉમેરવાની યોજના છે, આ પ્લેટફોર્મ વપરાશકર્તાઓને ધિરાણ વિકલ્પોની તુલના કરવાની, શ્રેષ્ઠ દરો અને સુરક્ષિત ભંડોળ શોધવાની મંજૂરી આપે છે.

કોફાઉન્ડર અને CEO રોહિત માથુરની આગેવાની હેઠળના બ્રિજને ક્લબ બ્લુ ઇન્ડસ્ટ્રી પાર્ટનર તરીકે નિયુક્ત કરવામાં આવ્યા છે, જે AAHOAના પ્રોગ્રામમાં સર્વોચ્ચ સ્તર છે, તેના 300 ભાગીદારોમાંથી માત્ર 12 જ લાયકાત ધરાવે છે, એમ બંનેએ સંયુક્ત નિવેદનમાં જણાવ્યું હતું.

Keep ReadingShow less
2025માં મંદીની સંભાવના 50 ટકા : HAMA સર્વે

2025માં મંદીની સંભાવના 50 ટકા : HAMA સર્વે

HAMA 2025 સર્વે: 49% મેનેજર્સ મંદીની આશંકા ધરાવે છે

હોસ્પિટાલિટી એસેટ મેનેજર્સ એસોસિએશનના સ્પ્રિંગ 2025 ઇન્ડસ્ટ્રી આઉટલુક સર્વેક્ષણમાં અંદાજે 49 ટકા ઉત્તરદાતાઓ 2025 માં અમેરિકામાં મંદીની અપેક્ષા રાખે છે, જે 2024ના પાનખર સર્વેક્ષણમાં 19 ટકાથી વધુ છે. ટોચની ત્રણ ચિંતાઓ માંગ, ટેરિફ અને DOGE કટ અને વેતનમાં વધારો વચ્ચેનો જોડાણ છે.

HAMA સર્વેક્ષણમાં જાણવા મળ્યું છે કે લગભગ 55 ટકા ઉત્તરદાતાઓએ તેમની વર્તમાન વ્યૂહરચનાના ભાગ રૂપે બ્રાન્ડ અથવા મેનેજમેન્ટ ફેરફારો કર્યા છે અથવા કરવાની યોજના બનાવી છે.

Keep ReadingShow less
AAHOA Bridge AAHOALending 2025

AAHOA, Bridge launch AAHOALending.com

AAHOA and Bridge Unveil AAHOALending.com at AAHOACON 2025

AAHOA AND BRIDGE launched AAHOALending.com, a digital lending platform focused on hospitality. It offers AAHOA members access to more than 150 lenders, with plans to add more regularly, while allowing users to compare financing options, find the best rates and secure funding.

Bridge, led by Cofounder and CEO Rohit Mathur, has been named a Club Blue Industry Partner, the highest level in AAHOA’s program, with only 12 of its 300 partners qualifying, the duo said in a joint statement.

Keep ReadingShow less
HWIC WHLA partnership 2025

HWIC joins WHLA to support industry women

HWIC Becomes WHLA’s 34th Member in 2025

THE HOSPITALITY WOMEN’S Innovation Council recently joined as the 34th member of the Women in Hospitality Leadership Alliance to support women and underserved communities across the industry. The council will encourage women to take part in the messaging, programs and initiatives shared by all WHLA groups.

WHLA was founded in 2021 as a consortium of organizations working to advance women in hospitality.

Keep ReadingShow less